Dried down beautifully! Did not smudge with gloss.

Incredibly satisfied with my purchase! This will definitely be a staple in my makeup routine!

literally the best black liquid lipstick i’ve ever used!!

Oh. My. Goth. This black lipstick stays on all night & doesn't dry you out!! The lip liner is perfect, I'm obsessed. Wish I tried this brand sooner!

3rd buy of Nightmare I cannot get enough! Apocalypse is theee nicest liner! So happy this was a set.